Following a contentious selection process, Florida A&M University hired a new president with no experience working in higher education but longstanding ties to Republican Governor Ron DeSantis.
Marva Johnson, a lobbyist for Charter Communications, faced sharp opposition from students and alumni, who dubbed her “MAGA Marva.” But despite questions about her lack of experience, Florida A&M’s board voted 8-4 in a Friday meeting to make her the next president.
Johnson was also criticized by community members and Board Chair Kristin Harper for her salary demands, which included base pay of $750,000 plus performance bonuses. (Two other candidates requested compensation in the $500,000 range, while one other was negotiable.)
Harper was one of the four trustees who voted against hiring Johnson.
“In an age of merit-based hiring decisions, how can one justify settling for a candidate who does not meet all of the position criteria? Or turning a blind eye to exceptionally qualified candidates?” Harper asked.
She added that FAMU community members “have been very clear” with their feedback.
But other trustees emphasized Johnson’s experience in the political world. Jamal Brown, the faculty senate president who sits on the board, argued that FAMU needed a president who has “access and political connections” to ensure the university’s financial success. In voting for Johnson, he argued that “this moment calls for someone who understands the systems that fund and govern us, because right now our survival depends on how we navigate those systems.”
While Johnson has never worked in higher education in any capacity, she spent eight years on the Florida State Board of Education, including time as chair. During the hiring process, critics highlighted her lack of experience, as did some trustees who voted against her.
Johnson beat out Donald Palm, executive Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of Florida A&M, who received four votes. Other candidates included Rondall Allen, provost and Vice President for Academic Affairs at University of Maryland Eastern Shore, and Gerald Hector, senior Vice President for Administration and Finance at the University of Central Florida.
Palm, the internal candidate, was overwhelmingly endorsed by FAMU’s alumni association.
At a tense meet-and-greet with Johnson on Wednesday, the candidate assured the university community she was “not a Trojan horse” and promised she “would fight and win for FAMU.”
However, critics have argued she failed to articulate a clear vision for the university.
Additional drama accompanied the hire when the board cut Harper out of contract negotiations. While board chairs have traditionally negotiated the contract with incoming presidents at Florida A&M, trustees voted to delegate that responsibility to another member at Friday’s meeting.
“I take personal offense at what is happening,” Harper said during that discussion.
Another controversy arose earlier in the search amid speculation that Johnson was added at the last minute to a list of three finalists. Last month trustee Ernie Ellison called to restart the search, arguing “there are too many clouds hanging over this process.” He stepped down earlier this month and was quickly replaced by a new DeSantis appointee, who then voted to hire Johnson.
Johnson steps into the FAMU job, which is currently held by an interim, after Larry Robinson, who led the university from 2017 to 2024 resigned amid controversy over a fraudulent gift.
Last spring Florida A&M announced at commencement that the university had received a $237 million donation from Greg Gerami, a relatively unknown businessman with no connection to the institution. Florida A&M appeared to ignore warning signs that Gerami had also pledged $95 million to Coastal Carolina University in 2020, despite having no ties to CCU other than previously dating an employee. Gerami walked that donation back due to what he viewed as disrespect by officials at Coastal Carolina. Gerami’s FAMU donation was later invalidated.
Despite the opposition to her candidacy, Johnson fits the profile favored in recent years by the governing boards at Florida’s public institutions, which have emphasized non-traditional applicants. Johnson is one of multiple presidential hires with ties to DeSantis or the GOP since 2022, when the state legislature passed a bill allowing universities to shield applicant identities until the end of the hiring process, breaking with long-standing tradition of making those names public. State lawmakers recently proposed injecting more transparency into searches but that effort failed.
Other political hires include Ben Sasse, a former Republican Senator from Nebraska, who had a short-lived presidency at the University of Florida, former lieutenant governor Jeanette Nuñez at Florida International University, and former state lawmakers Adam Hasner at Florida Atlantic University and Richard Corcoran at New College of Florida, among several others. Former GOP lawmaker Ray Rodrigues was also hired to lead the State University System of Florida in 2022.
The University of Florida is currently in the process of replacing Sasse with an interim appointed to the job after his abrupt departure. Sole finalist Santa Ono, a traditional academic who left the University of Michigan to take the Florida job, marks a reversal of course compared to recent hires. However, Ono’s candidacy has sparked criticism from some conservative power players.
